Skip to content
ferndean

Original research

We read a year of video from 2,260 school district YouTube channels. 94% had no real captions

In October we checked 17 district channels by hand. This time we found every district channel we could from the districts' own websites and read each one's last 12 months of uploads: 107,402 videos, about 95,000 hours. 5.9% of the videos had captions someone uploaded or corrected. 80% of the districts captioned none. This is a picture of habits a year or more before the ADA Title II deadlines, not a list of violations, and we don't name any district.

Check your videos free

Published

Key findings

  • 5.9% of videos had real captions. Of 107,402 videos posted from November 2025 to November 2026, 6,342 had a caption track that was uploaded or edited rather than generated automatically by YouTube. By hours it's 3.7%: the longer the video, the less likely it was captioned.
  • 80% of districts captioned nothing. 1,814 of 2,260 districts had no captioned video in the year. 10 captioned every video.
  • It isn't just small channels. 1,159 of the 1,482 districts that posted 10 or more hours captioned none.
  • A typical district posted 21 hours in the year. The median was 26 videos and 20.8 hours; one district in ten posted more than 96 hours.
  • Livestreams are three-quarters of the hours. 72,756 of the 95,382 hours were livestream replays, and 2.8% of those hours were captioned.
  • Board meetings are the biggest single kind of video. About 41,600 hours, 6.8% captioned. Sports came next, about 30,100 hours, almost none captioned (0.1%).
  • Virginia led the states, with 33.5% of videos captioned. Alaska, Maine, New Hampshire and the Bureau of Indian Education schools captioned none.
Districts by share of their videos captioned
2,260 district channels, uploads from the last 12 months
None
1,814
1–24%
285
25–49%
72
50–74%
52
75–99%
27
All
10

What districts post

We sorted each video by its title. Board and committee meetings, budget hearings and work sessions are “board”. Games, highlights and anything with “vs” are “sports”. Graduations, concerts, ceremonies and tours are “events”. Everything else (announcements, features, short clips) is “other”. Titles are a rough guide, so treat the split as approximate.

Hours posted in the year, by kind of video
95,382 hours on 2,260 district channels
Board and committee meetings
41,607
Sports
30,078
Events and ceremonies
9,885
Everything else
13,813
Share captioned, by kind of video
VideosHours
Board and committee meetings
6.2%
6.8%
Sports
0.7%
0.1%
Events and ceremonies
5.0%
2.9%
Everything else
7.7%
3.1%
28,357 board, 17,289 sports, 11,236 event and 50,520 other videos, published in the 12 months before each scan (November 13–14, 2026).

Short videos are where districts do caption: the “everything else” group is half the videos but a seventh of the hours, and it has the highest share captioned. The long recordings are where nothing happens. A board meeting runs about an hour and a half on average, and a game closer to two.

Month by month: a slow rise that didn't hold

Districts post on the school calendar: busy from September to June, peaking in May with graduations and end-of-year board meetings, and quiet in July. The share captioned crept up through the year, from 2.5% of the hours in December to 5.6% in August, then fell back to 2.9% in September, when the school year's board meetings and games came back.

Hours posted per month
All 2,260 district channels, December 2025 to October 2026
0
10,000
20,000
9,923
DecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOct
Share captioned per month
VideosHours
0%
5%
10%
5.6%3.3%
DecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOct
December 2025 to October 2026; the partial months at either end are left out.

Livestreams are most of the work

Share of hours captioned: livestreams against uploads
Livestream replays are 76% of the hours posted
Livestream replays
2.8%
Uploaded videos
6.6%
47,147 livestream replays (72,756 hours) and 60,255 uploads (22,626 hours).

Three hours in four were livestreams: board meetings and games streamed live and left on the channel. Once the stream ends, the replay is recorded video, and it needs accurate captions like any other upload. Live captions during the stream are a separate requirement. See livestream captions and do board meeting videos need captions?

Bigger channels caption more, up to a point

Districts captioning nothing, by channel size
Share of districts with no captioned video in the year
Under 1,000 subscribers
86%
1,000–5,000
75%
5,000–20,000
44%
20,000 or more
67%
1,341, 810, 89 and 18 districts; videos captioned: 3.6%, 5.0%, 12.6% and 8.7%. Two districts hide their subscriber count.

Most district channels are small: 1,341 of 2,260 have fewer than 1,000 subscribers, and 86% of those captioned nothing. Districts with 5,000 to 20,000 subscribers did the most, probably because they're larger districts with a communications team. Even there, 44% captioned nothing.

By state

States with at least five districts in the census, ordered by the share of videos captioned. A state's number depends on the few districts whose websites link their channel, and one big channel can move it, so read it as a snapshot, not a ranking of state policy.

Share of videos captioned, by state
States with at least five districts in the census; districts in brackets
All districts
Virginia (38)
33.5%
North Carolina (30)
18.9%
Colorado (36)
14.6%
Florida (18)
14.1%
Minnesota (93)
12.2%
Washington (31)
11.8%
Maryland (8)
11.4%
South Carolina (21)
10.6%
Indiana (89)
9.3%
California (218)
7.1%
Texas (164)
6.7%
Tennessee (36)
6.6%
Arizona (35)
6.5%
Oregon (36)
6.4%
Kansas (42)
6.3%
Michigan (64)
5.7%
Montana (9)
5.7%
Wisconsin (125)
4.6%
Iowa (55)
4.0%
New York (212)
3.8%
Nevada (6)
3.6%
Vermont (8)
3.1%
Missouri (65)
3.1%
Ohio (128)
2.8%
Kentucky (24)
2.5%
North Dakota (14)
2.5%
Connecticut (44)
2.2%
Alabama (25)
2.0%
Illinois (131)
1.8%
Mississippi (17)
1.7%
Oklahoma (33)
1.7%
Pennsylvania (150)
1.4%
New Jersey (103)
1.2%
Massachusetts (55)
1.1%
Georgia (6)
0.9%
Arkansas (10)
0.7%
Delaware (8)
0.6%
New Mexico (8)
0.4%
Utah (7)
0.3%
South Dakota (20)
0.1%
Alaska (8)
0.0%
Bureau of Indian Education schools (8)
0.0%
Maine (11)
0.0%
New Hampshire (5)
0.0%
Not shown (fewer than five districts with a linked channel): Wyoming (4), the U.S. Virgin Islands (1) and Puerto Rico (1). We found no linked district channels for Hawaii, Idaho, Louisiana, Nebraska, Rhode Island, Washington DC or West Virginia.

What the deadline covers

The ADA Title II web rule asks districts to meet WCAG 2.1 AA for the content they post online, YouTube included. The dates, as extended by an interim final rule in April 2026: April 26, 2027 if the population of the jurisdiction you serve is 50,000 or more, and April 26, 2028 if it's smaller. Check your deadline.

  • What you post after your date is covered. That's why this census reads the last 12 months: it's the best guide to what a district will be posting once its date arrives. At the median, that's about 21 hours of new video a year to caption.
  • Social media posts made before your date are exempt. Whether a YouTube upload counts as a social media post, DOJ didn't say, and it asked public entities to err on the side of accessibility. Most of the 107,402 videos here will probably never need captions. The habit is what matters.
  • Old video embedded on current web pages is covered unless it's properly archived. See the archived video exception.
  • Anything someone asks for has to be made accessible, exempt or not.

Read it as a measure of readiness. A district that captions nothing today has about a year or two to change how video gets posted, so captions are part of publishing rather than a backlog. More in ADA Title II video requirements and the Title II deadline checklist. This is general information, not legal advice.

How we did it

  1. 1

    Every district website

    We started from the 11,743 school districts with a website in the NCES Common Core of Data. We fetched each district's home page once (10,730 answered) and kept the YouTube links on it. 2,679 districts linked a channel. Where a page linked several, we preferred the district's own over an athletics or school channel.

  2. 2

    A year of uploads per channel

    For each channel we read every video published in the 12 months before the scan, with the YouTube Data API: length, whether it was a livestream, and its caption flag. 2,549 channels were read; 109 links pointed to channels that no longer exist, and 21 channels couldn't be read. 2,260 channels posted at least one video in the year, and those are the census. The scan ran on November 13–14, 2026.

  3. 3

    What counts as a real caption

    The API's contentDetails.caption field is true only when a video has a caption track that was uploaded or edited, not just YouTube's automatic track. We counted a video as captioned when it was true, as in our 17-channel scan.

  4. 4

    Kinds of video

    Livestream replays come from the API. Board meetings, sports and events are keyword matches on titles, checked in that order, so a video belongs to one group only.

Limitations

  • Only districts that link their channel. About a quarter of the district websites that answered linked a YouTube channel. Districts that don't may post less, or post on channels we didn't find. That probably makes this sample more active on video than districts overall.
  • One channel per district. Many districts also post on school, athletics or board-meeting channels, or host video on their own sites, Vimeo or Facebook. We read the district's main channel only.
  • Real captions aren't necessarily accurate captions. The flag says a track was uploaded or edited, not that it's correct. If anything, 5.9% overstates how many videos meet WCAG.
  • Kinds of video are title guesses. A meeting titled only with a date lands in “everything else”.
  • Audio description isn't measured. The API doesn't report it. In our 17-channel scan, no video mentioned it.

Check your own channel

Our free YouTube channel scan runs the same checks on every video on your channel and lists the ones without a real caption track, with livestream replays and likely audio description needs flagged. The website video check finds video embedded on your site, the part that's covered whenever it was posted.

Enter your website and we'll check it and the YouTube channel it links to.

Questions

What people ask first.

Something else? Send us a message

What counts as a “real caption” in this census?
A caption track someone uploaded or edited, which YouTube's API reports as contentDetails.caption = true. YouTube's automatic captions don't set that flag. A real track can still contain errors, so this is an upper bound on accurate captions.
Why don't you name districts?
The deadlines are a year or more away and old posts are probably exempt, so a district that captions nothing today isn't out of compliance. The census is about habits across the country, not any one district. You can check your own with the free scan.
Do these videos need captions?
Most of them probably never will: social media posts made before your deadline are exempt, though DOJ didn't say whether YouTube counts. Video posted after your deadline, and older video embedded on current web pages, does. See ADA Title II video requirements.
How is this different from your 17-channel scan?
The October scan took 20 districts at random and read every video they ever posted. This census reads the last 12 months from every district whose website links its channel, 2,260 in all. Both found the same thing: only a few percent of videos have real captions.
Can I use these numbers?
Yes, with a link to this page. The figures are from a scan run on November 13–14, 2026, and the limitations above apply.

Free video check

How accessible is your video today?

Enter your website. We find the videos embedded on it and scan the YouTube channel it links to: which have accurate captions, which likely need audio description, and how much new video you post a year. Free with your work email.

Enter your website and we'll check it and the YouTube channel it links to.