Skip to content
ferndean

Guide

The archived content exception, for video

Do your years of old videos have to be captioned? Some don't, if you set them up the right way. Here are the four conditions of the archived content exception, the other exceptions that touch video, the YouTube question, and how to build an archive page that holds up.

Check your videos free

Updated

The four conditions

The ADA Title II rule defines archived web content in 28 CFR 35.104, and HHS's Section 504 rule uses the same words in 45 CFR 84.10. Archived web content is content that:

  1. Was created before your compliance date, or reproduces paper documents or other physical media created before it;
  2. Is retained exclusively for reference, research, or recordkeeping;
  3. Is not altered or updated after the date of archiving; and
  4. Is organized and stored in a dedicated area or areas clearly identified as being archived.

All four have to be true. DOJ's fact sheet puts it plainly: “The exception does not apply unless all four points are present.” Because the first condition is tied to “the date the public entity is required to comply,” the cutoff is your deadline as extended: April 26, 2027 or April 26, 2028 for districts, May 11, 2027 or May 10, 2028 for HHS-funded providers. Check yours.

What that means for video, condition by condition

ConditionPassesFails
Created before the deadlineThe 2025 homecoming highlightsA video recorded after your deadline, even if you put it straight in the archive
Only for reference or recordsPast board meetings kept for the recordLast year's enrollment walkthrough still linked from the enrollment page
Not changed since archivingMoved to the archive and left aloneRe-edited, retitled into a new promo, or re-featured on the home page
Clearly labeled archive areaA page titled “Video archive” that says what it isOld videos mixed into the current “Board meetings” page

DOJ's own example is a town parade page: current details on top, plus “a separate archived section with several photos or videos from the parade in past years.” Those older videos “would likely be covered by the exception” if they meet the four conditions. A district's athletics page with this season's schedule and a clearly labeled archive of past seasons' highlight videos works the same way.

The other exceptions that touch video

  • Preexisting social media posts. A district's or provider's social media posts made before the compliance date are exempt (35.201(e), 84.85(e)). Everything posted after is covered.
  • Content posted by a third party, unless they post it “due to contractual, licensing, or other arrangements” with you (35.201(c), 84.85(c)). A parent's concert video on their own channel isn't yours. A video your booster club posts on the district channel, or one a vendor produces and posts for you, probably is.
  • Preexisting conventional electronic documents covers PDFs, word processing files, slides and spreadsheets. It doesn't cover video.

DOJ also noted that third-party content “should still be made accessible upon request when required under the existing obligations within title II.” Exempt from the technical standard isn't the same as off the hook.

The YouTube grey zone

Is a YouTube upload a social media post? Neither rule says. DOJ's examples of social media platforms are “Facebook, Instagram, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.” DOJ declined to “single out any individual social media platform” and asked public entities “to err on the side of ensuring accessibility where there are doubts about coverage.” In the HHS rulemaking, a commenter asked HHS to exclude content on platforms such as YouTube; HHS didn't.

Our reading: pre-deadline uploads that live only on YouTube are probably exempt, but unclear. We never call them exempt. Two cases are not grey at all: a YouTube video embedded on a current page of your own website is part of that page, and anything uploaded after your deadline is covered.

Exempt video still has to be provided on request

This is the part most districts miss. DOJ wrote that “upon request from a specific individual, a public entity may have to provide the web content … in an accessible format,” under its existing effective communication duties. For video specifically, DOJ said an entity may be “obligated to add captions to a video that falls within the archived content exception and provide the captioned video file to the individual with a disability who needs access to the video.” HHS made the same point for Section 504.

DOJ added that it “will often be most economical and logical” to post the captioned video publicly once it's fixed. So the archive turns your backlog into an on-request workload: you fix a 2023 meeting when a resident asks for it, not before. To make that work, people need a way to ask. Publish a request form and a turnaround you can keep.

How to set up a video archive page

  1. 1

    Sort your videos by date

    Split everything into before and after your compliance date. Only the before pile can be archived. Our free channel scan shows which of your uploads have real captions.

  2. 2

    Pull out what's still in use

    Anything people still need to use a service (enrollment, registration, how-to videos, safety procedures) isn't “exclusively for reference.” Caption and keep it on its current page, or replace it.

  3. 3

    Create a dedicated archive page

    One page, or a section, with “Archive” in its title and heading, for example “Board meeting video archive (before April 2027).” Link to it from your current pages as an archive, not as current content.

  4. 4

    Say what it is, and how to ask

    Put a short statement at the top: these videos are kept for reference and recordkeeping, haven't been updated, and anyone who needs an accessible version can request one. Link the request form.

  5. 5

    Move the old embeds

    Take the old videos off current pages (the board page, the athletics page, the home page) and embed or link them only from the archive.

  6. 6

    Leave them alone

    Don't re-edit, retitle or re-feature archived videos. If you need one in current use, caption it and treat it as new content.

  7. 7

    Nothing new goes in uncaptioned

    After your deadline, a new upload can't be archived into the exception. It needs captions and, where needed, audio description from day one.

Deleting old video is also allowed, but you lose the public record, and a video you take down may still be one someone asks for. For most districts, an archive page plus a request process is the better trade.

Ferndean's request page and 48-hour turnaround are built for exactly this: archived or not, when someone asks for a video, it gets accurate captions and description, and the request is logged for your report. See pricing.

Enter your website and we'll check it and the YouTube channel it links to.

Questions

What people ask first.

Something else? Send us a message

Are old school board meeting videos exempt?
They can be, if they're in a clearly labeled archive, kept only for the record, recorded before your deadline and not changed since. Old meetings on your current board page don't qualify. YouTube-only uploads are probably exempt as preexisting social media posts, but that's unclear.
Does the archive cutoff move with the deadline extension?
Yes. The definition uses the date you're “required to comply,” and DOJ and HHS both moved those dates in 2026. For a large district, video created before April 26, 2027 can qualify.
Is YouTube social media under the ADA Title II rule?
The rule doesn't say. DOJ's examples were Facebook, Instagram, X and LinkedIn, and it told entities to err on the side of accessibility when coverage is in doubt. Treat pre-deadline YouTube uploads as probably exempt, not exempt.
Do we have to caption an archived video if someone asks?
Yes, in most cases. DOJ said an entity may be obligated to add captions to an archived video and give the captioned file to the person who needs it. It's usually simplest to post the captioned version too.
Can we just delete our old videos?
Yes, the rules don't require you to keep them. But you lose the public record, and some content, like past meeting video, people may still request. An archive page with a request form keeps both.

Free video check

How accessible is your video today?

Enter your website. We find the videos embedded on it and scan the YouTube channel it links to: which have accurate captions, which likely need audio description, and how much new video you post a year. Free with your work email.

Enter your website and we'll check it and the YouTube channel it links to.