What the rules ask
WCAG 2.1 success criterion 1.2.4 (Level AA) says: “Captions are provided for all live audio content in synchronized media.” W3C's intent: captions that include dialogue, “identify who is speaking and notate sound effects and other significant audio.” Both the ADA Title II and Section 504 rules adopt it, with the same deadline as everything else.
DOJ thought hard about live captions in its 2024 rule. It declined to set an accuracy percentage or require a method, and left public entities “the flexibility to determine the best way to comply with this success criterion based on current technology.” In the same passage it recognized that “automatic captions are currently not sufficiently accurate in many contexts,” and pointed to W3C's guidance that they aren't sufficient on their own unless confirmed to be fully accurate.
Two limits on 1.2.4 worth knowing. It applies to broadcasts, not to two-way calls: W3C says it “is not intended to require that two-way multimedia calls between two or more individuals through web apps must be captioned regardless of the needs of users.” And live video needs no audio description; 1.2.5 covers recorded video only.
Option 1: YouTube Live's automatic captions
Free, and better than nothing. But read the conditions in YouTube Help:
- English only. “Automatic captions for live streams are available in English only.”
- Not every channel. YouTube says it is “slowly rolling out to channels with more than 1,000 subscribers.” Many school channels are smaller.
- Normal latency only. Low and ultra-low latency streams, including mobile streams, don't get them.
- Per stream. You turn them on for each live stream, not for the whole channel.
- Quality varies. YouTube says so itself, and adds: “We encourage creators to use professional captions first.”
- Gone afterwards. “After the live stream ends, live automatic captions won't remain on the video.” YouTube generates new automatic captions for the recording instead.
For a routine meeting with good microphones and clear speakers, live auto-captions may be a reasonable starting point. For events where accuracy matters most (a contentious vote, a public hearing, graduation names) they're a risk. Check how they perform on your own streams before relying on them.
Option 2: A human captioner (CART)
CART (Communication Access Realtime Translation) is a trained captioner writing what is said in real time, usually remotely. W3C's own example for 1.2.4 is an orchestra providing CART captioning of each web performance. Human captioners handle names, crosstalk and accents far better than speech recognition, and can mark speakers as they change.
YouTube Live supports outside captions two ways (YouTube Help):
- 1
Embedded captions from your encoder
If your encoder or captioning hardware supports it, choose EIA-608/CEA-708 (“embedded”) captions in your encoder settings. YouTube supports one caption track per stream.
- 2
Or captions sent over the internet
In YouTube's live settings, add a 30- or 60-second broadcast delay so the captions line up, then copy the caption ingestion URL from the Closed captions section.
- 3
Give the URL to your captioner
The captioner enters it in their software. YouTube lists supported tools including Total Eclipse, Case CATalyst, Caption Maker and StreamText.Net.
- 4
Test before the meeting
Run a private test stream with the captioner a day ahead. Send them the agenda and a list of names (board members, staff, schools) so they can prepare.
If your meetings stream through a meeting-video vendor rather than YouTube, ask whether they offer live captioning, whether it's automatic or human, and how they handle the replay.
Option 3: Captions from your meeting software
If the meeting runs in Zoom or a similar tool and is streamed from there, its captioning features or an assigned captioner can provide the live captions. DOJ mentioned this route itself: modern live captioning can be created “by assigning captioners through Zoom or other conferencing software.” Check that the captions actually reach the public stream viewers watch, not just the people in the meeting, and that someone owns turning them on before each meeting.
Choosing by event
| Event | Live captions | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Regular board meeting | Auto-captions with good audio, or CART | Ask the chair to state names and vote results aloud |
| Public hearing (budget, boundaries) | CART | High stakes, many unfamiliar speakers |
| Graduation | CART, with the names list in advance | Names are the point, and auto-captions miss them |
| Sports stream | Auto-captions if there's commentary | Without commentary, the live audio is crowd noise; the replay needs description, not just captions |
| Superintendent Q&A | Auto-captions or CART | Repeat audience questions into the microphone |
Then: the replay
When the stream ends and the video stays on your channel, it's recorded video. That brings in WCAG 1.2.2 (accurate captions) and, where the picture carries information the audio doesn't, 1.2.5 (audio description). In our scan of 17 district channels, livestream replays were among the most common uploads, and almost none had real captions.
- Live auto-captions are discarded. YouTube makes new automatic captions for the recording. They're a draft to correct, not a finished track.
- CART captions can be cleaned up. If you used a captioner, ask for the caption file afterwards, fix any errors, and upload it to the replay (how).
- Add speaker names if the live captions didn't have them.
- Check for audio description needs: a hand vote, slides nobody read, a scoreboard. See when audio description is required.
- Do it soon. Residents look up a meeting in the days after it happens. Set a target (for example, accurate captions within a few business days) and put it in your video policy.
Ferndean handles the replay side for districts: when a stream ends and the replay is on your channel, it's captioned accurately with speaker names, published back to YouTube, and described if it needs it. See how it works for school districts.
Sources
- WCAG 2.1, Understanding 1.2.4 Captions (Live)
- DOJ final rule, 89 FR 31320 (April 24, 2024), live-audio captions discussion
- YouTube Help, Use automatic captioning
- YouTube Help, Add live captions to a live stream
- WCAG 2.1, Understanding 1.2.2 Captions (Prerecorded)
This is a reading of the rules, not legal advice. Something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.