Skip to content
ferndean

Captions

Closed captions vs open captions: which one your school or health center should use

Both kinds of captions put the words on screen. Only one of them lets you fix a mistake after you publish, so here is a simple rule for each type of video you post.

Check your videos free

Published

The difference in one sentence

Closed captions are a separate text track that viewers turn on and off. Open captions are text burned into the picture itself, so they show for everyone and can't be turned off.

On YouTube, closed captions live in a file attached to the video. YouTube Help lists the caption file formats it accepts, from basic SubRip (.srt) and SubViewer (.sbv) to WebVTT (.vtt), TTML, SAMI and the broadcast format SCC, which it names as its preferred format. That page covers only caption files uploaded separately from the video. It says nothing about burned-in text, because to YouTube, burned-in text is just part of the picture.

Open captions are made in your editing software before you export. Once the video is rendered, the words are pixels. Nothing downstream knows they are captions.

Do open captions meet WCAG 2.1 AA?

The ADA Title II rule for public entities and the Section 504 rule for HHS-funded organizations, such as health centers, both adopt WCAG 2.1 AA as the standard for web content. WCAG asks that prerecorded video with sound have captions. Its caption requirement is about whether accurate, in-sync captions are there. It does not say the captions must be switchable.

So open captions can count, as long as they are complete and accurate: every spoken word, who is speaking when it isn't obvious, and sounds that matter, such as applause or an alarm. Burned-in text that only shows key phrases, the way many social clips do, is a design choice, not captioning. If you want to know what accurate looks like, see caption quality standards.

This is a plain reading of the standard, not legal advice. If your organization has a specific legal question, ask your counsel.

Why closed captions are the better default

Open captions can pass. Closed captions are still the better choice for almost everything you post on YouTube and your website. Here is why.

  • You can fix errors. A misspelled drug name or a wrong board member name in a caption file takes minutes to correct. In burned-in text it means re-editing, re-exporting and re-uploading, and the new upload loses its views and link.
  • You can add speaker names later. Board meetings and panels need them. With a caption file you add them in a text editor.
  • Viewers control the look. People who need larger text, a different color or a dark background can change closed captions in their player. Burned-in text stays the size and color you picked.
  • The text is readable by machines. A caption track is text that platforms and screen readers can use. Burned-in text is part of the image.
  • You can add more languages. A Spanish track can sit next to the English one. With open captions you would need a second video. See Spanish captions for school videos.

There is one more YouTube detail. YouTube Help says automatic captions are made by machine learning, vary in quality, and are published to the video automatically when available. It encourages creators to add professional captions first. The page doesn't say whether auto-captions skip videos that already have burned-in text, so a viewer could end up seeing your open captions and an auto-caption track at the same time. That's an inference, not something YouTube states, but it is worth checking on any open-captioned video you upload. For more on auto-captions, see are YouTube auto-captions ADA compliant?

Where open captions earn their place

Use open captions where a platform makes closed captions hard to add or manage, or where a screen has no caption controls at all.

  • Short social clips. A 30-second game highlight or a flu shot reminder on a platform where uploading a caption file is awkward or unsupported.
  • Feeds that autoplay muted. People scroll past with the sound off. Burned-in captions carry the message without a tap.
  • Lobby and waiting-room screens. A TV in a clinic waiting room or a school front office usually plays a file on a loop with no caption menu.

If the same video also goes on YouTube or your website, upload a clean version there with a closed caption track. Keep the burned-in version for the place that needs it.

Pitfalls of burned-in captions

The FCC's caption rules for television don't govern your YouTube channel, but they set a useful bar. The FCC placement standard says "Captioning shall be viewable and shall not block other important visual content on the screen," including faces, featured text such as graphics and credits, and other essential information. With closed captions, the player often handles this. With open captions, you do. Watch for these problems:

  • Covering on-screen text. Captions at the bottom can sit right on a lower third that names the speaker, a phone number or a dosage chart.
  • Weak contrast. White text with no background disappears over a bright gym floor or a white lab coat. Use a solid or semi-opaque box behind the text.
  • Cropping. A 16:9 video with captions near the edges loses words when a platform crops it to vertical. Make vertical versions from the source, not from the captioned export.
  • Errors you can't take back. Once it's posted, a typo stays until you replace the whole video.
  • No viewer control. People who need bigger text can't get it.

Captions are only half of it

Open or closed, captions serve people who can't hear the soundtrack. They do nothing for people who can't see the picture. WCAG 2.1 AA also asks for audio description when the picture shows something the soundtrack doesn't: a slide with a phone number nobody reads aloud, a nurse demonstrating an inhaler without saying each step, a scoreboard.

Burned-in text makes this easier to miss. If your open captions repeat the narration, fine. But if you added on-screen text that isn't spoken, such as a title card, a URL or a date, a blind viewer gets none of it. Read when audio description is required, or try the check below on one of your videos.

1. What's on the soundtrack?
Answer the questions about one video to see whether it needs audio description.

Which videos have to meet the rules, and by when

Under the ADA Title II rule, as extended in 2026, public entities serving 50,000 people or more have until April 26, 2027, and smaller ones and special districts have until April 26, 2028. Under the Section 504 rule, HHS-funded organizations with 15 or more employees have until May 11, 2027, and those with fewer have until May 10, 2028. Check your date.

1. What kind of organization are you?
Answer the questions to see your deadline.

Old video isn't automatically off the hook. The archived content exception applies only when all four conditions hold: the video was made before the deadline, it's kept only for reference, it hasn't changed since, and it sits in an area clearly labeled as an archive. Being old isn't enough. See the archived video exception.

Social media posts made before the deadline are exempt, but neither DOJ nor HHS said whether YouTube counts as social media. That makes pre-deadline YouTube uploads probably exempt (unclear). Video embedded on current pages of your website is in scope. And any video someone asks for has to be made accessible either way.

A quick rule for each type of video

Video typeWhere it goesUseWatch for
Board meetingsYouTube, websiteClosed captions with speaker namesNames spelled right; see board meeting captions
Announcements and superintendent or CEO messagesYouTube, website, emailClosed captionsOn-screen dates and links also need to be spoken or described
Patient educationYouTube, website, waiting-room screenClosed captions online; open captions on the lobby screenDrug names and doses; see patient education captions
Short social clipsSocial feedsOpen captions if the platform makes caption files hardContrast, cropping, covering on-screen text
Livestream replaysYouTubeClosed captions, corrected after the streamLive auto-captions alone usually fall short; see livestream captions
For live video itself, WCAG 1.2.4 asks for captions on the live audio. The replay is recorded video and needs accurate captions.

Here is what you can do this week:

  1. 1

    Scan your channel

    Run the free YouTube channel scan to see which videos have only auto-captions, which have real caption tracks, and which are likely in scope.

  2. 2

    Check your website

    Run the website video check. Embedded videos on current pages are in scope, wherever they're hosted.

  3. 3

    Find your burned-in videos

    List any open-captioned videos on YouTube or your site. For the ones you'd want to fix, locate the clean source file so you can upload a version with a closed caption track.

  4. 4

    Set the rule in writing

    Add one line to your process: closed captions on YouTube and the website, open captions only for social clips and lobby screens. The video accessibility policy template has a spot for it.

Ferndean is in early access, enrolling pilot districts and health centers for spring 2027. Once pilots begin, it will add checked closed captions with speaker names to each new upload on your YouTube channel, so errors can be fixed and viewers can resize the text. To see where your channel stands today, scan your channel.

Enter your website and we'll check it and the YouTube channel it links to.

Sources

This is a reading of the rules, not legal advice. Something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.

Questions

What people ask first.

Something else? Send us a message

Do open captions meet ADA requirements?
The ADA Title II and Section 504 rules adopt WCAG 2.1 AA, which asks for accurate captions on prerecorded video but doesn't require them to be switchable. Complete, accurate open captions can count. Closed captions are still the better default because you can correct them and viewers can restyle them.
Should I burn captions into board meeting videos?
No. Board meetings are long, have many speakers and often need corrections to names. A closed caption track on YouTube lets you fix errors and add speaker names without re-uploading.
Can YouTube show auto-captions on top of my burned-in captions?
YouTube Help says auto-captions are published automatically when available and doesn't say whether burned-in text prevents that. Check any open-captioned upload to make sure viewers don't see two sets of text.
Do captions replace audio description?
No. Captions help people who can't hear the soundtrack. When the picture shows something the soundtrack doesn't, WCAG 2.1 AA also asks for audio description.
Do I need to recaption old YouTube videos with burned-in text?
YouTube uploads made before your deadline are probably exempt (unclear), but videos embedded on current website pages are in scope. Anything someone asks for has to be made accessible either way.

Free video check

How accessible is your video today?

Enter your website. We find the videos embedded on it and scan the YouTube channel it links to: which have accurate captions, which likely need audio description, and how much new video you post a year. Free with your work email.

Enter your website and we'll check it and the YouTube channel it links to.