The rule in one sentence
WCAG 2.1 success criterion 1.2.5 (Level AA) says: “Audio description is provided for all prerecorded video content in synchronized media.” That sounds like every video, but W3C's own explanation narrows it: “if all of the important information in the video track is already conveyed in the audio track, no additional audio description is necessary.” Both the ADA Title II and Section 504 web rules adopt WCAG 2.1 AA, so this is the test you work to.
Audio description is a narration of what's on screen, voiced in the pauses between speech, for people who are blind or have low vision. W3C says it covers “actions, characters, scene changes, and on-screen text that are important and are not described or spoken in the main sound track.”
Two questions decide it
- Is there something on screen that matters? Text, a score, a chart, a name, an action that changes what the video means.
- Is it said out loud? If the narrator, presenter or announcer says it, the soundtrack already carries it.
If the answer to the first is yes and the second is no, the video needs audio description. Anything else, captions are enough. A useful trick: play the video with your eyes closed. Wherever you'd have to ask “what just happened?”, that's a description.
District and health center examples
| Video | Needs description? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Superintendent's message to camera | No | Everything is spoken. The picture is a person talking. |
| Board meeting where every vote is announced | No | The results are in the audio. |
| Board meeting with a hand vote and no announced count | Yes | Who voted how is only in the picture. |
| Football highlight reel set to music | Yes | The plays, the players and the score are only on screen. |
| Basketball game replay with full play-by-play | Little or none | The announcer describes the action. Describe the score if it's never called. |
| Game stream with no commentary | Yes | Nothing in the audio says what's happening. |
| Graduation ceremony | Usually some | Speeches are spoken, but names shown only on screen, the processional and the moment diplomas are handed over may need a line. |
| Budget presentation with unread slides | Yes | The numbers on the slides are the content. |
| Bus safety video with on-screen tips and music | Yes | The tips are text on screen. |
| Patient portal walkthrough clicking through screens silently | Yes | The steps are only shown. |
| Nurse demonstrating an inhaler while explaining each step | No | Each step is said as it's shown. |
The pattern: talking heads need none, music-over-pictures always does, and meetings and events depend on whether the people in them say what's happening.
Two cases trip people up. Scoreboards: in a game replay, the announcer may call plays but never the score, the clock or the down. If the score matters to the video (and in a highlight reel it always does), describe it when it changes. On-screen text: W3C says that, generally, all text in the video should be either spoken in the main audio or included in the description. That includes lower-third name titles, phone numbers, dates and web addresses at the end of a promo.
What doesn't need description
- Live video, while it's live. 1.2.5 covers prerecorded video only. But the replay that stays on your channel is recorded, so it's in scope once posted. See livestream captions.
- Decoration. You don't need to describe the color of the backdrop or that the presenter is wearing a blue jacket, unless it matters.
- Audio-only content. A podcast has no picture. It needs a transcript instead (WCAG 1.2.1).
- A video whose visuals are all spoken. W3C even lists a short text note, “a static text alternative to describe a talking head video,” as one way to meet 1.2.5 when the picture is just someone speaking.
Silent video is its own case: WCAG 1.2.1 asks for a text alternative or an audio track for video with no sound at all, like a silent slideshow of the new building.
Standard vs extended audio description
Standard description fits into the natural pauses. The video plays at normal speed and the narrator speaks between lines of dialogue. That's what WCAG 1.2.5 asks for at Level AA.
Extended description pauses the video to make room when the pauses aren't long enough. W3C describes it as “periodically freezing the synchronized media presentation and playing additional audio description.” It is WCAG 1.2.7, Level AAA, so the rules don't require it. W3C does list it as one way to meet 1.2.5, and it can be the only workable way to describe a busy video, such as a fast-talking lecture over constantly changing slides.
For most district video, standard description works: highlight reels have music, not speech, so there's room; meetings have long stretches of silence during votes and transitions.
Avoid it at the source: integrated description
W3C calls it integrated description: the information is “naturally woven into the script for the main speaker(s).” It costs nothing and helps everyone, including people watching on a phone without looking.
- Meetings: have the chair announce every vote result and the no votes by name.
- Presentations: read the headline number off each slide.
- Promos: have the narrator say the text that appears on screen, including the web address.
- Events: have the announcer read names as they appear on screen.
When a video needs it
On YouTube, the common approach is a described version: the same video with descriptions voiced in the pauses, posted as its own video and linked from the original. Some channels can also add a descriptive audio track to the original. The full set of options is in how to add audio description to YouTube.
Ferndean flags which of your videos likely need description in the free channel scan, then writes the description for the pauses, voices it and links the described version for each new upload that needs it.
Sources
- WCAG 2.1, Understanding 1.2.5 Audio Description (Prerecorded)
- WCAG 2.1, Understanding 1.2.7 Extended Audio Description (Prerecorded)
- WCAG 2.1, Understanding 1.2.3 Audio Description or Media Alternative
- WCAG 2.1, Understanding 1.2.1 Audio-only and Video-only (Prerecorded)
- W3C WAI, Description of Visual Information
This is a reading of the rules, not legal advice. Something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.