The short version
- One advocate filed about 2,400 web accessibility complaints starting in 2016, and about 1,000 ended in signed resolution agreements with the Education Department's Office for Civil Rights (OCR).
- Uncaptioned video was among the problems cited, alongside sites that couldn't be used without a mouse or by blind users.
- The agreements followed a pattern: adopt a web accessibility policy, name a coordinator, audit the website, fix what the audit finds on a schedule, train staff every year, and report to OCR until it closes the case.
- Video cases went further. The Justice Department found UC Berkeley's YouTube videos largely uncaptioned; Berkeley pulled more than 20,000 recordings from public view, and later signed a consent decree. Harvard and MIT settled captioning lawsuits in 2019 and 2020 with deadlines for new video and on-request captioning of older video.
The 2016–2018 wave of OCR complaints
In 2016, Marcie Lipsitt, a disability rights advocate in Franklin, Michigan, began filing complaints with OCR about inaccessible education websites. By August 2016, Education Week reported she had filed about 500. Her targets included every state education department and the country's 100 largest school districts, as well as charter schools, virtual schools and schools for the deaf and blind. The problems she reported included sites that were hard or impossible to use for blind people, sites that couldn't be navigated without a mouse, poor color contrast, and videos without captions.
By April 2018, The 74 reported, she had filed roughly 2,400 web accessibility complaints, and about 1,000 had led to signed resolution agreements. Those included 26 state education departments and several of the largest school districts in the country. At one point OCR was opening as many as 150 new investigations a month from her complaints. Each took her about 30 minutes to file.
In March 2018, OCR changed its Case Processing Manual to let it dismiss complaints that were part of “a pattern of complaints” filed by one person or group against many institutions. The 74 reported that more than 550 pending investigations tied to Lipsitt's complaints were dismissed. OCR removed that provision in its November 2018 manual.
What a typical OCR resolution agreement required
OCR publishes its resolution agreements. The 2017 agreements from this period follow a common template. The one signed by Northview Public School District on October 11, 2017 (OCR docket 15-17-1403) is typical. Under it, the district agreed to:
- 1
Measure against a standard
Accessibility of online content would be measured against WCAG 2.0 Level AA (the version current at the time) and WAI-ARIA, or another standard that makes the content accessible. The agreement noted the standard was guidance, not a safe harbor.
- 2
Adopt a web accessibility policy
Draft a policy by a fixed date and submit it to OCR for approval, then post it on the website and notify students, employees and guests. The policy had to name the standard, designate a web accessibility coordinator with resources and authority, and tell people how to report problems or file a grievance.
- 3
Cover third-party content, including YouTube
Set a procedure so that content from vendors and “video-sharing websites such as YouTube” that the district chooses to make available on its website is accessible.
- 4
Audit and fix
Complete an initial audit within 180 days of OCR approving the policy, and annually after that. Write a corrective action plan with timeframes, start it within 30 days of OCR's approval, and within 180 days certify to OCR that the online content meets the standard.
- 5
Train staff every year
Train everyone who develops or distributes online content, including administrators, teachers, staff and volunteers, on the policy and on making web design, documents, course content and multimedia videos accessible. Report names, titles and materials to OCR.
- 6
Report until OCR closes the case
Send OCR the policy, audit report, corrective plan, certification and training records on set deadlines. OCR could visit, interview staff and ask for more data, and could start enforcement proceedings if the district didn't follow through.
The agreement for Fayette Local Schools, signed in September 2017 (docket 15-17-1332), has the same structure, including the YouTube language and the 180-day audit.
Notice what's missing: no fines, no damages. The cost is the work, on someone else's timetable, with a federal agency reviewing each step. A policy, a coordinator, an inventory and a request log are the things these agreements made districts build after the fact; building them before a complaint is much cheaper.
The video cases: Berkeley, Harvard and MIT
UC Berkeley and the Justice Department (2014–2022)
- Investigation: the Justice Department opened an investigation into the accessibility of UC Berkeley's online content in October 2014.
- Findings, August 30, 2016: DOJ told Berkeley its YouTube content wasn't accessible. Of more than 500 videos it reviewed, about 11.7% had manual captions; the other 88.3% had no captions or YouTube's automatic captions, “which was often inaccurate or incomplete”.
- Video removal, March 2017: Berkeley announced it would end public access to more than 20,000 audio and video recordings, saying disability access requirements forced the decision. Critics, including accessibility researchers writing in Inside Higher Ed, pointed out that DOJ's letter hadn't asked for any content to be removed.
- Lawsuit and consent decree, November 21, 2022: DOJ filed suit, saying that in 2021 over 20,000 Berkeley YouTube videos still had no captions or only automatic ones, which lack punctuation and can't identify speakers. In a proposed consent decree filed the same day, Berkeley agreed to make all future and the vast majority of existing online content accessible, revise its policies, train staff, designate a web accessibility coordinator, test its content and hire an independent auditor, over three and a half years.
Harvard and MIT (2015–2020)
- The suits: the National Association of the Deaf and individual plaintiffs sued Harvard and MIT in federal court in 2015 over uncaptioned online video.
- Harvard, November 2019: Harvard agreed to caption new online videos it creates, including on YouTube and Vimeo, to caption existing content back to January 2019, and to provide live captions for events streamed online. It doesn't cover content Harvard shares but didn't create.
- MIT, February 2020: MIT agreed to caption video and audio it creates and posts on its website and its YouTube, Vimeo and SoundCloud pages, and to provide live captions for certain streamed events. Under the consent decree, captions are defined by WCAG 2.1 AA, including speaker identification and non-speech sounds. New content is captioned when posted; content from January 1, 2019 on is captioned within a year; older content is captioned or removed within 7 business days of a public request. Replays of livestreams are captioned within 7 business days of posting.
These are universities, not school districts, and they were settled under the ADA and Section 504 before the new web rules. But they show what a negotiated fix looks like for video specifically: a date after which every new upload is captioned, a cutoff for older content, a public way to ask, and a short turnaround when someone does.
What this means now
- The rule raises the floor. The DOJ rule sets WCAG 2.1 AA and a fixed date (April 26, 2027 for districts serving 50,000 or more people, April 26, 2028 for smaller ones). A complaint after that date doesn't have to argue what the standard is. Check your deadline.
- Expect the same remedies. Policy, coordinator, audit, corrective plan, training and reporting have been OCR's toolkit for years. You can adopt them on your own terms with our video accessibility policy template.
- New video first. Every video case set a date after which all new video is captioned when posted. That's the part to fix first, and the part that never stops.
- Older video on request. MIT's decree let older content be captioned or removed within 7 business days of a request. Under the new rules, properly archived video is exempt, older YouTube-only video is probably exempt but that's unclear, and anything someone asks for must be made accessible. A public request page and a log handle that.
- Removing video is a choice, not a fix. Berkeley's removal drew criticism and didn't end the matter: DOJ sued five years later. Archive deliberately, and keep current content accessible.
Ferndean is built around that pattern: accurate captions on every new upload, audio description where needed, a public request page with a 48-hour turnaround, and a report you can show your board or OCR. Start with a free channel scan.
Sources
- Education Week, Advocate moves needle on website accessibility (August 2, 2016)
- The 74, A civil rights activist filed thousands of disability complaints (April 18, 2018)
- Franczek, Web accessibility: OCR is back. Is your website ready?
- OCR resolution agreement, Northview Public School District, Docket 15-17-1403 (October 11, 2017)
- OCR resolution agreement, Fayette Local Schools, Docket 15-17-1332 (September 25, 2017)
- United States v. Regents of the University of California, complaint (N.D. Cal., November 21, 2022)
- Inside Higher Ed, Access Denied (April 17, 2017)
- Higher Ed Dive, UC Berkeley agrees to make online content accessible (November 23, 2022)
- NBC Boston, Settlement reached in suit over video captioning at Harvard (November 27, 2019)
- PBS NewsHour, MIT to caption online videos after discrimination lawsuit (February 18, 2020)
- NAD v. MIT, consent decree (via DREDF)
- DOJ interim final rule extending the compliance dates, 91 FR 20902 (April 20, 2026)
This is a reading of the rules, not legal advice. Something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.